“French ship designers were cleverer than English ones; French ships were usually faster” (Hotspur, 81). All of these years I’ve thought that one of the main reasons the English Navy dominated the seas was the fact that they had better ships. I could swear I remember reading or hearing about how the British ship designs were more advanced. Though come to think of it, that was in relation to ships of the Spanish Armada. Perhaps the same wasn’t true for French ships.

3 Comments:
Actually, the real reason the British dominated the seas was because the French navy was virtually non-existent until Napoleon decided he wanted one. And even then, the french navy wasn't as disciplined as the RN. The British were well-trained and had strength, tactics, and numbers and the french were generally better with the technology (exploding shot and rockets and such). The British were big ones for tradition (still are, really) and the French at that time were big into finding ways to tip the odds, because they knew they weren't on an even playing field.
The oddest were the Spanish ... they imported Irish shipbuilders to build enormous ships based on the English designs. The hierarchy of their navy was built on their aristocracy. So, picture this: the captains often had never been on a boat before, but they were some Lord of this or that, and their ships were designed without regard for practicality, but REALLY BIG (the Sanctissima Trinidad was 130 guns and made out of sandalwood or some such so it could still float). I can just hear the shipbuilders: "We'll show those English bastards ... we'll make the biggest goddamn ship anyone's ever seen ... they'll be sorry for everything they ever did to Ireland ..."
And the Spanish fleet based every action not on trying to win, but on honour ... before Trafalgar, the Spanish Captains all prepared to die ... not hoped and prayed to win ... to die in an honourable way.
It's funny, too, because their attitudes were all illustratd in the names of their ships. The English ships were all named things like "Victory", "Mars", "Defiance", "Swiftsure," the French: "Fougueux" (Impetuous), "Indomptable" (Untameable), and "Intrepide" (that one's obvious). The Spanish were all named after Saints, the Blessed Virgin and the Holy Trinity.
Sorry for that. But your post was SUCH an invitation. :o)
Oh, and the Armada was more than 200 years earlier ... things change over that time.
Wow, I always thought that the French had a lousy military, but the Spanish didn't even have thier heads attached.
Post a Comment
<< Home